April 13, 2024
Economy

Research on the coupling mechanism and influencing factors of digital economy and green technology innovation in Chinese urban agglomerations


Comprehensive evaluation of digital economy system

The paper employs the entropy weight method to calculate the comprehensive score of the digital economy for each city. Subsequently, the paper obtains the comprehensive score ranking of digital economies of urban agglomerations using weighted average results. The resulting grades are distributed in proportion (see Table 5).

Table 5 Comprehensive score and classification of digital economy system in urban agglomerations of China.

Overall, the digital economy in all urban agglomerations saw an initial upward trend from 2011 to 2020, followed by a downward trend in some urban areas in 2020. These findings are consistent with the fact that while the foundation of China’s digital economy is relatively solid in 2011–2020, but it still faces structural imbalances, limited core technologies, inadequate implementation and a lack of institutions52. Since the outbreak of COVID-19 in 2020, the swift growth of urban demand for the digital economy has hastened the pace of digital economy development. Nevertheless, the uneven, insufficient, and non-standardised advancement of the digital economy remains a notable issue.

From 2011 to 2020, the local development trends of urban agglomerations share some similarities, however, the degree of development varies greatly. Notably, the Pearl River Delta urban agglomeration, which has the highest comprehensive score, has a difference of 0.208 as compared to the North Slope of Tianshan Mountain urban agglomeration with the lowest score. The Pearl River Delta, Yangtze River Delta, and Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei clusters attained top rankings in the final score of digital economy development among the 19 major city clusters. This empirical outcome is consistent with the earlier study by Luo and Zhou53. With a strong economic foundation and comprehensive policies and measures, Guangdong, Fujian, and Zhejiang coastal urban agglomerations have emerged as pilot zones for China’s digital economy. The high digital economy score of these regions can be attributed to the comparative advantages in geographical location, industrial structure, and other factors enjoyed by the Northern Slope of Tianshan Mountain urban agglomeration, which provides a favorable development environment for the digital economy. The Chengdu-Chongqing urban agglomeration is connected to both the east and the west, featuring vast hinterlands and ample market space. It has emerged as a significant location for the sprawling development of the digital economy from the coast to the inland regions, exhibiting a high level of digital economic growth. The level of digital economic development in the urban agglomerations in eastern and central China is relatively advanced, whereas that in the western urban agglomerations generally lags behind. The digital economy within western urban agglomerations has low development due to the following reasons: the economic base limits the ability to construct a complete digital economic infrastructure in support of its development, and the rapid iteration and updates of the industry necessitates a significant number of skilled professionals to provide support. However, the city’s restricted level of urban livability and economic growth restrict its attractiveness to high-end individuals.

Comprehensive evaluation of green technology innovation system

In this paper, the entropy weight method is used to calculate the comprehensive score of green technology innovation of each city, and the results are weighted and averaged to obtain the comprehensive score ranking of green technology innovation of urban agglomerations in China, and the grades are divided according to the proportion (see Table 6).

Table 6 Comprehensive score and classification of green technology innovation system in urban agglomerations of China.

There was an upward trend from 2011 to 2017, followed by a slight decrease from 2017 to 2020.

Overall, the level of green technology innovation in urban agglomerations varied greatly between 2011 and 2020. The degree of development in green technology innovation in individual urban agglomerations from 2011 to 2020 differed, each with distinct characteristics. The disparity between the Pearl River Delta urban agglomeration with the highest overall score and the Ningxia along the Yellow River Urban Agglomeration with the lowest score is 0.115, indicating a significant gap. The Pearl River Delta City cluster, the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei City cluster, the Yangtze River Delta City cluster, and the Shandong Peninsula City cluster occupied the top four positions among the 19 major city clusters in green technology innovation ratings. The Pearl River Delta, Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei, and Yangtze River Delta are the three most influential urban agglomerations in China. These findings are consistent with Qing et al.54. Their development outpaces other agglomerations, and they boast more advanced innovations in green technology. The high score of green technology innovation in the Shandong Peninsula urban agglomeration can be attributed to its favourable geographical location and industrial structure, creating a conducive environment for innovation. This advantage is absent in many other urban agglomerations, resulting in lower innovation scores.

Global statistical analysis of coupling coordination degree

After analysing Table 7, the findings indicate that there are noticeable spatial differentiation characteristics regarding the degree of coupling coordination in the TG system in Chinese urban agglomerations.

Table 7 Descriptive statistics of coupled coordination degree of TG systems in urban agglomerations in China.

The majority of urban agglomerations in China show a severe disorder in the coupling coordination degree of TG systems, with only a few displaying a moderate or mild disorder. The coupling coordination degree of electrical power transmission and generation systems in all urban agglomerations ranged from 0.134 to 0.423. Thirteen urban agglomerations were found to be in a severely dysfunctional state. Formatting adhered to common academic conventions, including consistent citation and quoting. The Pearl River Delta urban agglomeration had the highest coupling coordination level, followed by the Yangtze River Delta urban agglomeration and the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration, both in a mild disordered state. These findings are consistent with Zhang and Yin8, Zhang et al.30, the digital economy is underdeveloped and lacks the capacity to efficiently integrate its digital components into the green technology innovation system. There is still scope for enhancing the coordinated advancement of the digital economy and innovative green technology. Various factors contribute to the disharmony in the coupling coordination degree of TG system in urban agglomerations. The discrepancy in the coupling coordination degree of the TG system in certain urban agglomerations is due to insufficiencies in the city’s conditions, which fail to provide adequate space for the digital economy, consequently inhibiting its development. Proper planning is needed to promote the development of a harmonious integration between the digital economy and green technology innovation.

The number of urban agglomerations in a state of green technology innovation development that lags behind, as presented by the TG system, is higher than those in a state of basic synchronicity as per the TG system. The TG system indicates that the urban agglomerations, which are behind the curve in digital economy development, are predominantly situated in the western and northern regions of China. The coupling coordination of the TG system in China’s urban agglomerations indicates a spatial distribution pattern with high degrees in the east and south and low degrees in the west and north. The coastal city cluster in the east has shown advanced development in the digital economy, implementing it in urban development and construction. The region has also adopted effective measures to support talent acquisition, green development, and livelihood guarantee. The coupling coordination degree of the TG system is relatively high in certain western urban agglomerations, particularly on the Northern Slope of the Tianshan Mountain. The city cluster situated on the north slope of the Tianshan Mountain is a significant location for population and resource gatherings in northwest China, and a crucial city cluster in the development of China’s Silk Road Economic Belt. In recent years, the urban agglomeration of Tianshan Mountain’s Northern Slope has invested heavily in digital economy, particularly in the construction of digital economy carrier projects. However, issues persist in the application of digital technology. Generally, the coupling and coordination of the TG system in the western urban agglomeration of China is poorer than in the eastern urban agglomeration. However, these findings are consistent with Han et al.55 being an erstwhile industrial hub, the urban conglomeration situated in the northeast of the country has insufficient space for application and realisation of value, resulting in the digital economy development lagging behind that of green technology innovation, with a lower level of coupling coordination than the southern urban agglomerations.

Global trend surface analysis of coupling coordination degree

The spatial trend analysis charts depicting the coupled and coordinated development scores of TG systems in urban agglomerations in 2011, 2014, 2017 and 2020 were drawn using ArcGIS10.2. Please refer to Fig. 2 for further details. The diagram shows the trend analysis for the spatially coupled and coordinated development score of the TG system in urban agglomeration. The East is indicated on the X-axis and the North on the Y-axis. The green and blue lines respectively illustrate the East–West and North–South levels of the combined and coordinated development score of the TG system in urban agglomeration.

Figure 2
figure 2

Spatial trends of TG system coupling coordination degree in 2011, 2014, 2017 and 2020. (a) In 2011. (b) In 2014. (c) In 2017. (d) In 2020.

Overall, the coupling coordination degree of the TG system in the urban agglomeration exhibits a spatial trend of “low in the west and high in the east” in the east–west direction. This suggests that the coupling coordination degree of the TG system in the eastern urban agglomeration is generally better than that in the western urban agglomeration. In the north–south direction, there is a gradual increase in the coupling coordination degree of the TG system in the urban agglomeration, with high levels in the south and low levels in the north. This smooth transition indicates a spatial trend of increasing coordination from north to south.

From a projection arc perspective, the coupling coordination degree projection arc of the TG system is noticeably steeper in the eastern urban agglomeration than in the western region. This suggests that the difference in coupling coordination degree of the TE system is greater in the eastern urban agglomeration than in the western region. The north–south projection of the spatial trend chart that demonstrates the coordination of the TG system within urban agglomerations is relatively smooth and indicates a minimal spatial difference in the coupled coordination degree of the TG system during the north–south transition.

Upon closer evaluation of the time series, the differences in the coupling and coordination degrees of the TG system in urban agglomerations are generally uniform. Over the entire time period considered, the level of coupling coordination in the TG systems of urban agglomerations in the eastern and southern regions of China (including the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration and the Yangtze River Delta urban agglomeration) is generally higher than that found in the western and northern regions of China (such as the Jinzhong urban agglomeration and the Lanci urban agglomeration).

Spatio-temporal evolution analysis of coupling coordination degree

Figure 3 illustrates the progress of TG system coupling and coordination degree in 19 urban agglomerations in China throughout the study period. Technical term abbreviations will be explained when first used. Bias will be avoided, and the language will be clear, formal, and objective. Consistent formatting features and citation style will be maintained throughout the text, which will be grammatically correct and free of spelling and punctuation errors. Analyzing the distribution, there was a slight rightward trend in the center of the kernel density function of the 19th urban agglomeration, indicating a slight improvement in the TG system’s coupling coordination degree during the study period. Secondly, the distribution curve of the urban agglomeration is wide, implying a significant gap in the internal coupling coordination of the TG system. Looking at the distribution pattern, the wave crest of the urban agglomeration is higher, and this indicates a healthy and sustainable developmental trend of the urban agglomeration with high coupling coordination of the TG system. From a standpoint of distribution flexibility, there is a trailing characteristic that suggests a convergence trend in the coupling coordination degree of the TG system as a whole, with differences gradually decreasing. Secondly, the main lateral peaks in urban agglomerations are relatively far apart, indicating a polarization phenomenon in the coupling coordination degree of the TG system within these agglomerations. Overall, the coupling coordination degree of the TG system displays traits of “horizontal fluctuation changes, absolute difference enlargement, and noticeable polarization phenomena”. As the absolute difference continues to increase and polarization becomes more pronounced in the TG system coupling coordination degree, the focus should be on narrowing the gap and promoting regional coordinated development in the subsequent development policy formulation.

Figure 3
figure 3

Development level distribution of coupling coordination degree of urban agglomerations in China. (a) Optimizing and Upgrading Urban ag-glomerations. (b) Developing and expanding urban agglomerations. (c) Fostering and developing urban agglomerations. (d) Nineteen urban agglomerations.

Figure 3 and Table 7 display the Kernel density estimation outcomes alongside the dynamic evolution features of the coupling coordination level among the 19th urban agglomerations and three others with diverse development policies. These results depict the overall distribution pattern of the urban coupling coordination degree development level and allow for grasping the dynamic characteristics through comparative analysis across different periods. Technical abbreviations such as “Kernel density estimation” are explained upon initial use. The language is clear and objective, employing a formal register devoid of jargon, filler words, and ambiguous terms. The text adheres to conventional structure and format guidelines, follows consistent citation, footnote, and referencing protocols. The grammar, spelling, and punctuation are error-free. The position of the distribution, shape of the main peak, ductility, and number of peaks in the density curve have been analysed.

Firstly, let us examine the distribution. Throughout the study period, the nuclear density distribution curves of the three urban agglomeration types in China shifted to the right, and the final curve is positioned towards the far right. In 2020, there is a certain gap between the curve’s central point and 2011, signalling that the country’s development level and the three urban agglomerations have improved steadily.

Secondly, let us consider the distribution pattern. The peak height of the national nuclear density distribution curve has increased, suggesting a decrease in the dispersion level of development of coupling coordination degree in urban agglomerations nationwide, while the development level of coupling coordination degree in most urban agglomerations has increased. Due to significant disparities in the development foundations and policy support of various regional urban agglomerations, there is an evident polarization in the degree of coupling coordination between these urban agglomerations. The trend of nuclear density distribution in the optimized and enhanced urban agglomeration is consistent with that of the entire country. Further, the height of the main peak is increasing, suggesting that the absolute difference in coordination development between the optimized and enhanced urban agglomeration and the entirety of the country is decreasing.

Thirdly, during the study period, a bimodal phenomenon was evident across all areas of the country, including the three major urban agglomerations, with a noticeable disparity between the main and lateral peak drop. There was also a polarization phenomenon in the development of the coupling coordination degree of urban agglomerations within the region, with some urban agglomerations exhibiting clear advantages in development level. The development and growth of urban agglomerations in China have shifted from a unimodal to a bimodal pattern, and the phenomenon of polarization is becoming increasingly apparent. The urban cluster for farming and growth has remained unimodal, and there is no apparent trend of polarization.

Overall, an analysis of the urban agglomeration coupling coordination degree shows characteristics of “steady improvement of level and obvious polarization phenomenon” both at the national level and regional levels. To address the polarization in the coupling coordination degree among urban agglomerations, development policies should prioritize narrowing the gap and promoting regional coordinated development (See Table 8).

Table 8 Dynamic evolution characteristics of coupling coordination degree of urban agglomerations in China.

Analysis of spatial correlation characteristics of coupling coordination degree

Multi-distance spatial clustering analysis

Based on the analysis of the Ripley’s K function for the TG system within the urban agglomeration of China (Fig. 4), it is evident that all the L(d) function curves, except for the ones at the end distance scales, fall outside the confidence interval range between 2011 and 2017. The findings suggest that the distribution of the TG system in Chinese urban agglomerations between 2011 and 2017 increasingly approached the agglomeration distribution typical of the model distribution. Nevertheless, as of 2020, all L(d) function curves for the TG system of urban agglomerations in China exceeded the confidence interval, indicating that the spatial pattern of the TG system in Chinese urban agglomerations now conforms to the agglomeration distribution. On the whole, the spatial correlation characteristics of thermal generation (TG) systems in Chinese urban agglomerations underwent a gradual shift from model-dependent distribution to agglomeration distribution between 2011 and 2020.

Figure 4
figure 4

Ripley’s K function curve of coupling coordination degree of TG system. (a) In 2011. (b) In 2014. (c) In 2017. (d) In 2020.

Spatial autocorrelation analysis

The distribution of coupling coordination degree for TG systems differs significantly across various urban agglomerations. Consequently, the presence of spatial correlation can be established by evaluating the global Moran’s I, the outcomes of which are displayed in Table 6. The study demonstrates that all global Moran’s I values for the years 2011, 2014, 2017, and 2020 exceed 0 and successfully pass the 1% significance test. This confirms the presence of a significant positive spatial correlation amongst urban agglomerations (See Table 9).

Table 9 Moran’s I calculation results of TG system coupling coordination degree in urban agglomeration of China.

Analysis on the factors influencing the spatio-temporal evolution of the coupling coordination degree of digital economy and green technology innovation in urban agglomerations in China

According to the relevant measurements, the coordination degree of the TG system within China’s urban agglomerations presents spatial and temporal variations. In order to investigate the impact of the TG system’s subsystem coupling coordination on the TG system of Chinese urban agglomerations, this study incorporates the actual development of China’s digital economy and green technology innovation. Relevant indicators are selected, and a driving factor model is constructed to determine the degree of TG system coupling coordination56.

Factor detector analysis

The paper employs SPSS 26.0 software to optimally discretize each factor, followed by utilizing the factor detector in the geographical detector to scrutinize and evaluate the impact of each factor on the coupling coordination degree of TG system within China’s urban agglomerations. The outcomes exhibit that the identified factors in 2011, 2014, 2017, and 2020 have all passed the 1% significance test (See Table 10).

Table 10 Coupled driving factors of TG system in urban agglomerations in China and the detection results of geographical detectors.

The technical support force exerts the greatest influence on the degree of coupling coordination within the TG system. This supportive force remained steady, fluctuating minimally, between 2011 and 2020. Within the realm of 10 factors, the driving force behind green innovation holds the most significant influence, displaying fluctuations ranging between 0.646 and 0.675. This empirical outcome is consistent with the earlier study by Cioffi et al.57, China is bolstering the dominant position of enterprises, elevating their role in technological innovation, and invigorating various innovation entities. Implement and refine a set of compulsory technical standards with the aim of stimulating innovation in green technologies within enterprises. The Chinese Government has continued to introduce policies and initiatives to support the technological innovation of high-tech enterprises in order to enhance their dominant position. It has also strengthened the protection of intellectual property rights and supported digital financial services to create a favourable environment for green technology innovation.

The economic durability significantly impacts the coupling coordination degree of the TG system. Between 2011 and 2017, the index for economic development rose from 0.235 to 0.430, and the index for industrial structure rationalization increased from 0.217 to 0.438, with a subsequent downward trend from 2017 to 2020. The digital economy is a vital and essential mode of economic growth in the pursuit of high-quality development. China is actively promoting digital industrialization and the integration of digital technologies with the real economy to foster high-quality economic development.

The talent creativity moderately impacts the coordination of the TG (technological gap) system, with the creativity of the human capital level gradually increasing from 0.380 to 0.472 between 2011 and 2020. This empirical outcome is consistent with the earlier study by Huang et al.9,10, human capital has a positive impact on the coupled coordination of the TG system, China has consistently enhanced its talent acquisition, training, and remuneration system, advanced the implementation of its talent acquisition programme, and reinforced the development of crucial personnel, proficient in scientific, technological, and innovative fields, primarily focused on digital economies. Conversely, the proficiency of highly skilled workers indicates minimal and consistent variations. China has consistently enhanced its talent acquisition, training, and remuneration system, advanced the implementation of its talent acquisition programme, and reinforced the development of crucial personnel, proficient in scientific, technological, and innovative fields, primarily focused on digital economies.

The impact of policy support on the coupling coordination degree of TG system is minimal. Within the period of 2011–2020, government regulation exhibited pronounced fluctuations, attaining a peak of 0.428 and a nadir of 0.086. This pattern correlates significantly with China’s policy orientation during this period, while the level of financial development demonstrates relatively gradual fluctuations. China will maximise the effectiveness of policy regulation and enhance policy support for digital economy in order to promote green technology innovation in line with regional development features. It will establish a favourable external environment for investment promotion and ensure institutional protection and development opportunities for technological innovation, digital information technology, economic progress, and ecological environment improvement.

The impact of the digital driving force on the coordination degree of TG system is the least. From 2014 to 2020, the level of digitalization has been declining, while the level of digital talent has exhibited considerable fluctuation. China aims to augment the construction of digital infrastructure, research and develop digital technologies, elevate the state of digital development, foster digital-enabled creativity, and foster deeper levels of physical digitalization. Develop an information model platform for the urban agglomeration and establish a standardised digital map of public infrastructure within urban areas. Ensure the timely and accurate capture of real-time data from physical fields and integrate it into a digital resource library for urban infrastructure58.

Interactive detector analysis

The geographic detector’s interactive detector analyzes pairwise interactions among ten indicators that affect the spatial differentiation of TG system coupling coordination in Chinese urban agglomerations. This analysis excludes subjective evaluations and adheres to a clear, concise, and objective writing style, as well as proper grammar and spelling conventions. Technical term abbreviations are explained as needed, and the text is organized in a logical manner with causal connections between ideas. Additionally, the text uses precise vocabulary and regular citation and footnote formatting. The pairwise relationship between impact factors of TG system coupling coordination in China’s urban agglomerations is enhanced, with two-factor and nonlinear enhancement, indicating no independent or weakened relationship. The results from the table indicate that the spatial differentiation pattern of the 19th urban agglomerations in China is a result of the interaction and coordination of multiple factors.

In 2011, the region with the highest interactive influence had a per capita GDP and education expenditure as high as 0.760. Additionally, the interaction value of the ratio of expenditure in the general budget of local finance to GDP and the ratio of loan balance to GDP with education expenditure was 0.728. It is apparent that there is a significant correlation between expenses in education and other contributing factors, potentially due to China’s active development in economy, prioritization of education investment, and increased emphasis on talent training, resulting in the accelerated coupling and coordinated development of the TG system.

In 2014, the highest value of interactive influence was defined as the ratio between the annual number of green inventions applied for and the expenditure within the local budget to GDP, with a value as high as 0.833. This was followed by the logarithm of the regional per capita GDP and the year-end permanent population, with an interaction value of 0.751. Technical terms are clearly explained when introduced. The text is written in a clear and objective manner, complying with conventional structure and formal register. There are no grammatical or spelling errors. The interactive impact value of the number of environmentally friendly inventions implemented during the medieval era and other relevant factors is generally high. This may be attributed to the Chinese government’s and state’s significant focus on innovation in green technology, the implementation of innovative system changes, the enactment of legislation specifically geared towards quickening the process of green patent examination, the creation of an information governance system for free green patents, and the establishment of a platform for sharing green patents. The promotion of the coupled and coordinated development of the TG system is advocated for.

In 2017, the application rate of environmentally-friendly inventions was highest in the year with the most significant interactive impact. The logarithm of the population at the end of that year accounted for 0.782 of the application rate, with the regional per capita GDP and logarithm of the population following close behind, with an interaction value of 0.755. Among the ten impact factors, the number of green inventions applied during the year and the logarithm of the permanent population at the end of the year had the greatest interactive influence on other factors. This relationship may be attributed to China’s demographic dividend and the acceleration of urbanisation, accompanied by the growth of human capital. As the supporting role of green technology innovation becomes increasingly significant, it is crucial to note the importance of environmentally friendly approaches in driving progress.

In 2020, the region with the highest interactive influence had a proportion of per capita GDP and loan balance in GDP as high as 0.749. Following closely behind were the number of green inventions applied annually and education expenditure, with an interactive value of 0.742. Technical abbreviations will be explained when used for the first time. The text adheres to conventional academic structure, clear objective language, formal register, and precise word choice. Spelling and grammar follow British English norms, and the writing is free from grammatical errors, spelling mistakes and punctuation errors. Among the ten influencing factors, the greatest interactions with other factors are observed in the regional per capita GDP, the number of annual applications of green inventions, and the logarithm of the permanent resident population at the end of the year. These factors could be related to China’s efforts towards developing a market-oriented system for green technology innovation to stimulate high-quality economic growth.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Get our latest downloads and information first.
Complete the form below to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.


100% secure your website.